← All decision tools

03 / CAR & CASH FLOW

Buy with cash, finance, or lease?

Compare three ways to drive the same car through the end of a lease. See the money left after payments, the value of a car you own, and what could change the result.

01 / YOUR NUMBERS

Build your comparison

Use written quotes for the same car and the same period. This model assumes you could pay the full cash price today.

Loan quote

Enter the interest rate charged on the balance. An advertised APR can include fees; enter upfront loan fees separately so they are not counted twice.

Lease quote

Upfront lease cost excludes regular monthly payments and refundable deposits. If “due at signing” includes the first monthly payment, subtract that payment here; the model counts every monthly payment.

Return assumptions edit scenarios

Illustrative effective annual investment returns after fees and taxes. These are assumptions, not forecasts.

No account required. Inputs are calculated for this request and are not saved.

Worked example shown. Change the inputs to see your own comparison.

02 / THE COMPARISON

A clearer picture.

Estimated loan payment: $594.04/month. Equal monthly budget: $594.04.

AT LEASE END · MIDDLE RETURN ASSUMPTION

Buy with cash leads.

It finishes about $225 ahead of the next modeled choice after 3 years.

Buy with cash

$43,983modeled net position
$22,983 invested$21,000 car value$0 loan left

Buy with a loan

$42,171modeled net position
$34,439 invested$21,000 car value$13,268 loan left

Lease and return

$43,758modeled net position
$44,158 invested$0 car value$0 loan left$400 return costs

Net position = invested money + estimated car value − remaining loan − lease return costs. The lease is returned at the end; it creates no vehicle asset. Each option starts with $36,000 and uses the same monthly budget.

03 / OVER TIME

The full trajectory

Middle case: 5.0% assumed annual return

$45,181$32,802
0123
Buy with cashBuy with a loanLease and return

Years from today · modeled position. The owned car's value is estimated on a straight line between purchase and resale; lease return costs occur at the end.

View the modeled position at every year
Middle return assumption · 5.0% effective annual return; car value is illustrative before the final year.
YearBuy with cashBuy with a loanLease and return
0$36,000$35,750$34,000
1$38,290$37,430$37,222
2$40,945$39,561$40,606
3$43,983$42,171$43,758
04 / THE TIPPING POINTS

What could change the answer?

7.7%

At this steady effective annual return, cash and loan purchases finish approximately level. It is a break-even calculation, not a return target.

At the middle return, cash purchase and returned lease meet at about $20,775 resale value. Above that estimate cash purchase leads the lease; below it the lease leads. The loan may still be the highest of all three.

05 / RETURN SENSITIVITY

Change the return.
See the choice shift.

Editable, steady annual return assumptions after fees and taxes. They are illustrations, not probabilities or forecasts.

Investment returnBuy with cashBuy with a loanLease and returnHighest position
Lower 2.0%$43,015$39,303$40,278Buy with cash
Middle 5.0%$43,983$42,171$43,758Buy with cash
Higher 8.0%$44,978$45,209$47,437Lease and return

06 / RESALE SENSITIVITY

What if the car
is worth less?

This stress test moves your resale estimate 20% down and up while holding the middle investment return fixed. The 20% range is an illustration, not a predicted price range. Lease return value remains zero.

Owned car resaleBuy with cashBuy with a loanLease and returnHighest position
20% lower $16,800$39,783$37,971$43,758Lease and return
Your estimate $21,000$43,983$42,171$43,758Buy with cash
20% higher $25,200$48,183$46,371$43,758Buy with cash

THE DECISION GUIDE

Read the result
in context.

Use the model to compare written quotes, then check the details it cannot price for you.

01 / CASH

What does cash give up?

A cash purchase avoids loan interest but uses the full purchase price today. The comparison assumes that money is actually available and invests the same monthly budget that a loan or lease would have required. Keep an emergency reserve outside the amount you commit.

02 / LOAN

What does financing preserve?

A loan leaves some cash available to invest, but adds interest and possibly upfront fees. If the loan is longer than the lease period, the unpaid balance is deducted at the comparison date. A longer term can lower the monthly payment while increasing total interest.

03 / LEASE

What happens at return?

The lease path returns the vehicle at term end, pays the entered return and excess-use costs, and has no car value left. It does not model buying the vehicle, signing a new lease, an early exit, or refundable deposits. Review mileage limits, wear rules, and insurance requirements.

04 / SCOPE

What belongs in the quotes?

Use an all-in cash purchase price including taxes and purchase fees, add loan fees paid upfront, and enter lease payments and nonrefundable upfront or return costs. Fuel, insurance, maintenance, tax treatment, incentives, trade-ins, and differences in driving limits are not modeled separately. Currency changes the symbol only.

A WORKED EXAMPLE

One car, three ways to pay.

Suppose a car costs $36,000 all-in. After 3 years, an owned car may sell for $21,000. A loan uses $6,000 down, 7.0% annual interest over 5 years, and $250 upfront fees. Its scheduled payment is about $594 per month. A lease requires $2,000 upfront, $470 per month, and $400 on return.

Illustrative net position after 3 years · same starting cash and monthly budget
Approach2% return5% return
Buy with cash$43,015$43,983
Buy with a loan$39,303$42,171
Lease and return$40,278$43,758

Amounts are rounded. The lease is returned, while owned paths include the estimated resale value and any unpaid loan. Cash and loan meet at about 7.7% assumed annual return in this example. Results are educational illustrations, not forecasts.

COMMON QUESTIONS

Before you sign.

What if I do not have the full cash price available?

This three-way comparison assumes you could pay the full all-in price today. If you cannot, the cash option is not feasible for you. Compare the loan and lease terms with your actual budget rather than treating the cash result as a recommendation.

Why does the loan still have a balance at lease end?

A loan can last longer than a lease. The model compares all options when the lease ends and subtracts any loan still owed. If the loan ends sooner, the freed monthly payment is invested for the remaining months.

Should I enter my quote's APR or interest rate?

Enter the fixed annual interest rate applied to the outstanding loan. APR can incorporate certain credit costs. Enter loan fees paid upfront separately, and avoid counting the same fee twice. The tool does not reproduce a lender's legal APR disclosure.

Does the lease include buying the car at the end?

No. This model returns the vehicle and deducts your expected return costs. A lease buyout needs another comparison using its actual buyout price, taxes, and fees.

How reliable is the resale estimate?

It is your assumption, not a guaranteed sale price. The resale sensitivity table shows what a 20% lower or higher value would do. The plotted values between today and lease end are straight-line illustrations; a car's actual market value can change differently.

Does the comparison cover insurance, maintenance, and mileage?

No. These can differ across contracts. Check what each quote includes, the lease's mileage and wear terms, and the full cost of ownership separately before choosing.

BEHIND THE NUMBERS

Understand the
calculation.

Each option begins with cash equal to the all-in purchase price. Unspent upfront cash and the unused part of one equal monthly budget are invested. The fixed loan amortizes monthly; cash and loan purchases include the same estimated resale value, while the returned lease has no car value and pays its entered end costs.

Investment returns and future resale are uncertain. This is a modeled comparison, not individualized financial advice.

Read the car comparison methodology