02 / HOME & INVESTING
Prepay your mortgage or invest?
Put the same available cash to work in three ways. Compare the mortgage balance, invested value, payoff time, and what happens when returns change.
Build your comparison
Use the interest rate charged on the remaining balance. A disclosed mortgage APR may also include fees and would not give the right scheduled payment here. We calculate principal and interest from your balance, rate, and years left.
Worked example shown. Change the inputs to see your own comparison.
A clearer picture.
Estimated scheduled principal-and-interest payment: $1,473.81/month.
UNDER YOUR MIDDLE RETURN ASSUMPTION
Invest instead leads.
It finishes about $4,567 ahead of the next modeled choice after 20 years.
Invest instead
50/50 split
Ending position = invested value − mortgage balance. The home's value is the same in every option and cancels out. Each option uses the same cash budget.
The full trajectory
Middle case: 6.0% assumed annual return
Years from today · ending position. Exact annual values are below.
Hover to compare monthly values. Drag to zoom, double-click to reset, or select a strategy in the legend.
View the ending position at every year
| Year | Prepay mortgage | Invest instead | 50/50 split |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | $-230,000 | $-230,000 | $-230,000 |
| 1 | $-219,913 | $-219,869 | $-219,891 |
| 2 | $-209,256 | $-209,146 | $-209,201 |
| 3 | $-197,998 | $-197,798 | $-197,898 |
| 4 | $-186,106 | $-185,787 | $-185,946 |
| 5 | $-173,542 | $-173,075 | $-173,309 |
| 6 | $-160,270 | $-159,621 | $-159,946 |
| 7 | $-146,249 | $-145,381 | $-145,815 |
| 8 | $-131,438 | $-130,310 | $-130,874 |
| 9 | $-115,790 | $-114,359 | $-115,075 |
| 10 | $-99,261 | $-97,477 | $-98,369 |
| 11 | $-81,798 | $-79,608 | $-80,703 |
| 12 | $-63,351 | $-60,696 | $-62,024 |
| 13 | $-43,863 | $-40,680 | $-42,272 |
| 14 | $-23,276 | $-19,495 | $-21,386 |
| 15 | $-1,528 | $2,928 | $700 |
| 16 | $21,478 | $26,661 | $24,054 |
| 17 | $45,865 | $51,780 | $48,749 |
| 18 | $71,714 | $78,366 | $74,862 |
| 19 | $99,114 | $106,505 | $102,476 |
| 20 | $128,159 | $136,289 | $131,722 |
What could change the answer?
5.6%
At this assumed annual return, prepaying and investing finish at approximately the same ending position.
Prepaying avoids mortgage interest under this fixed-rate model. Through the 20-year comparison, prepaying avoids about $82,052 of interest relative to investing all the extra cash.
A market return is uncertain; a mortgage balance reduction follows the contract. The threshold does not measure risk or the value of access to cash.
05 / SENSITIVITY
Change the return.
See the choice shift.
These returns are editable examples, not probabilities or predictions. The mortgage rate stays fixed in each row.
| Return scenario | Prepay mortgage | Invest instead | 50/50 split | Highest ending position |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lower 3.0% | $119,237 | $71,645 | $98,997 | Prepay mortgage |
| Middle 6.0% | $128,159 | $136,289 | $131,722 | Invest instead |
| Higher 9.0% | $137,690 | $234,427 | $181,192 | Invest instead |
THE DECISION GUIDE
Read the result
in context.
The highest modeled ending position is one part of the decision. These questions help interpret the tradeoff.
What does prepayment buy?
Extra principal reduces the balance on which future mortgage interest accrues. In this model the regular principal-and-interest payment stays the same, so the loan ends sooner. Confirm that your servicer applies extra payments to principal and check your loan terms for a penalty.
What does investing keep open?
An investment account may be easier to access than home equity, but its value can fall. A steady annual return in the model does not show the actual order of gains and losses. Protect money needed for emergencies or near-term spending.
Where does freed cash go?
All three options use the same lump sum and monthly budget. Once a mortgage is paid off, its former scheduled payment and extra cash are invested. This prevents the early-payoff option from looking weaker simply because its freed payment disappears from the comparison.
What is left out?
Home value is identical across options, so it cancels out. Property tax, insurance, escrow, mortgage insurance, tax deductions, penalties, fees, changing rates, and future home price changes are outside this model. The currency selector changes the symbol only.
A WORKED EXAMPLE
The same cash, three paths.
Take a $240,000 fixed-rate mortgage at 5.5% with 25 years left. The scheduled principal-and-interest payment is about $1,474 a month. A household can allocate $10,000 today and $400 each month. After 20 years, the middle 6% assumed investment return gives:
| Approach | Ending position | Mortgage balance |
|---|---|---|
| Prepay mortgage | $128,159 | $0 |
| Invest instead | $136,289 | $77,158 |
| 50/50 split | $131,722 | $0 |
At a lower 3% assumed return, prepaying ends at $119,237 and investing at $71,645. This change illustrates why the assumed return matters. The break-even return for this example is about 5.6%.
COMMON QUESTIONS
Before you move money.
Should I enter my full mortgage payment?
No. Enter the remaining balance, fixed interest rate, and years left. The tool calculates principal and interest only. Taxes, insurance, escrow, and mortgage insurance are not part of the comparison.
What if I only have a lump sum or only monthly extra cash?
Enter zero for the amount you do not have. At least one of the two available-cash inputs must be above zero. Any lump sum beyond the remaining mortgage balance is invested rather than discarded.
Does prepayment reduce my required monthly payment?
Not in this model. The scheduled principal-and-interest payment stays fixed; the mortgage pays off sooner. If your lender formally recasts or refinances the loan, that is a different cash-flow path.
Is the break-even return a target I can count on?
No. It is the constant annual return that makes the two modeled ending positions match. Actual investments fluctuate, and taxes, fees, penalties, and access to cash can change the decision.
Why can the break-even return differ from the mortgage interest rate?
The entered interest rate is applied to the loan balance each month at one-twelfth of its annual value; the investment input is an effective annual return. For example, 5.5% nominal annual mortgage interest compounds to roughly 5.64% over a year. The comparison also follows monthly cash flows.
Does the tool include a mortgage interest deduction?
No. Tax rules and eligibility depend on your location and circumstances. Enter investment returns after the fees and taxes you expect, and review mortgage tax treatment separately with a qualified adviser if it matters to you.
BEHIND THE NUMBERS
Understand the
calculation.
Mortgage interest accrues monthly at the entered annual interest rate divided by 12. Enter the rate applied to the balance, since a disclosed APR may also include fees. The scheduled principal-and-interest payment is calculated from the current balance and remaining term. Extra principal does not recast that payment. Investment growth uses an assumed effective annual return after fees and taxes.
This is an educational comparison, not a recommendation to buy an investment or prepay a particular loan. Read the full assumptions and limitations before acting.
Read the mortgage methodology