05 / HOUSING DECISIONS
Rent or buy?
Look past the payment.
Compare similar homes over the years you expect to stay. Add local buying and ownership costs, then see how a different home price or rent path changes the answer.
Build the housing comparison
Use a rent quote and purchase price for housing you would actually consider equivalent. Enter local taxes and fees rather than assuming another country's rules.
Worked example shown. Change the inputs for your housing choices.
A clearer picture.
Initial mortgage principal and interest: $1,439/month. Initial modeled housing outlay: buy $2,214 or rent $1,825 per month.
AT YEAR 10 · MIDDLE HOME-PRICE CASE
Renting leads in this model.
Its sale-adjusted position is about $7,985 higher at the chosen comparison date. Test the price and rent cases below before interpreting that lead.
Rent and invest
Both paths have the same available cash at the start ($69,000) and use the same housing budget each month. Unused cash is invested. The buyer's position assumes a sale, deducting 6.0% of the estimated sale value and the remaining mortgage. It is not cash available without selling.
The full trajectory
2.0% annual home-price case · 5.0% assumed return
Years from today · each owner point assumes a sale at that date and deduction of selling costs and mortgage balance. Values are scenario estimates, not forecasts.
Hover for monthly modeled positions, drag to zoom, or select a line in the legend. Each ownership point assumes a sale at that time.
View both paths at every year
| Year | Buy, then sell | Rent and invest |
|---|---|---|
| 0 | $42,000 | $69,000 |
| 1 | $50,587 | $77,223 |
| 2 | $59,469 | $85,471 |
| 3 | $68,659 | $93,733 |
| 4 | $78,171 | $101,997 |
| 5 | $88,020 | $110,253 |
| 6 | $98,223 | $118,486 |
| 7 | $108,795 | $126,683 |
| 8 | $119,754 | $134,828 |
| 9 | $131,120 | $142,905 |
| 10 | $142,911 | $150,896 |
What home-price change would level them?
2.2% a year
With the other entered assumptions fixed, this steady annual home-price change makes buying and renting finish approximately level at year 10.
A break-even rate is an algebraic threshold, not a prediction or a return you should expect.
05 / HOME-PRICE SENSITIVITY
If the sale price
changes the answer.
Editable annual price-change cases with the same mortgage, rent growth, and assumed investment return. These do not have probabilities.
| Price case | Buy, then sell | Rent and invest | Higher position |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lower -2.0% a year | $29,569 | $150,896 | Rent |
| Middle 2.0% a year | $142,911 | $150,896 | Rent |
| Higher 5.0% a year | $258,503 | $150,896 | Buy |
06 / RENT SENSITIVITY
If rent grows
slower or faster.
The table shifts your annual rent-growth assumption two percentage points down or up, within the form's allowed range. Other assumptions stay at the entered middle case.
| Rent path | Buy, then sell | Rent and invest | Higher position |
|---|---|---|---|
| Slower 1.0% a year | $142,911 | $176,125 | Rent |
| Entered 3.0% a year | $142,911 | $150,896 | Rent |
| Faster 5.0% a year | $154,420 | $134,474 | Buy |
THE DECISION GUIDE
Make the homes
comparable first.
Consider the amount of housing, the neighborhood, your moving plans, and the cash you still need for emergencies.
What must you put in?
Buying uses the entered down payment and purchase costs. Renting may have nonrefundable setup costs. Each path begins with the larger of those two upfront amounts available; any unspent part is invested. A refundable deposit and moving costs shared by both paths are outside this model.
What keeps getting paid?
The buyer pays the fixed scheduled mortgage amount until payoff, plus owner-only taxes, insurance, maintenance, and other costs. The renter pays rent and renter-only charges. Each month both paths have the larger of these outlays as a budget, and the cheaper path invests the difference.
What happens if you move?
The comparison assumes the owner sells at your chosen horizon. It deducts a percentage selling cost and pays the remaining mortgage from the sale value. A falling price can leave little or negative equity; selling may also take time and cost differently in your market.
Which local rules matter?
Use your actual purchase taxes, recurring owner-only charges, insurance, and selling expenses. The model does not calculate local tax benefits, transfer rules, rent controls, adjustable-rate loans, special mortgage structures, or eligibility. Currency changes only the displayed symbol.
A WORKED EXAMPLE
A similar home,
two ways to live in it.
Suppose a home costs $300,000 with $60,000 down and $9,000 in purchase costs. A 30-year fixed loan at 6.0% has about $1,439 monthly principal and interest. Comparable rent starts at $1,800 a month. Owner-only taxes, insurance, maintenance, and other costs total $3,600 + $1,500 + $3,000 a year, plus $100 a month.
| Annual home-price change | Buy, then sell | Rent and invest |
|---|---|---|
| −2% | $29,569 | $150,896 |
| +2% | $142,911 | $150,896 |
The example also assumes rent and other housing costs grow 3% a year, unspent cash earns a steady 5% annual return after tax, and selling costs are 6% of the sale price. Amounts are rounded. They are model assumptions, not local quotes or forecasts.
COMMON QUESTIONS
Before you choose a path.
Does the model treat rent as wasted money?
No. Both paths pay for comparable housing each month. The renter can invest cash the buyer used upfront and any monthly difference; the buyer builds equity and may gain or lose value. The comparison asks what each path might leave at the end under the same available cash budget.
Does my entire mortgage payment count as a cost?
The scheduled payment is a cash outlay in the equal-budget comparison. Part reduces principal, so the remaining mortgage balance is also subtracted from the home's estimated sale value. This keeps principal from being counted as a loss twice.
What if I stay beyond the mortgage term?
The scheduled payment stops once the fixed mortgage is paid. The owner still pays entered taxes, insurance, maintenance, and other costs; any monthly budget left over is invested. Try a horizon that matches your actual plans.
How should I enter local taxes and mortgage insurance?
Enter purchase taxes in upfront buying costs and only owner-only recurring taxes in the annual tax field. If a tax or utility charge applies equally while renting, leave it out of both paths. If mortgage insurance applies, you can include an estimated average in owner-only monthly costs. This model applies that amount throughout the horizon and cannot end it automatically; compare runs with and without it if the timing matters.
Is the break-even price change a forecast?
No. It finds the steady annual home-price rate where the two modeled positions meet at the chosen date, holding all other inputs fixed. Prices, rent, rates, returns, taxes, and unexpected repairs can differ substantially from the entered paths.
What if I might move soon?
Try a shorter horizon and realistic selling costs. Buying and selling can be expensive, and a home may not sell for your assumed value or on your schedule. Renting may also have nonfinancial benefits, such as flexibility.
BEHIND THE NUMBERS
Understand the
calculation.
Both paths start with the larger of buying or renter setup cash and use the larger monthly housing outlay as a common budget. The cheaper path invests its unused amount. The buyer's value at each date is invested money + estimated home value − selling costs − mortgage balance. The renter's value is invested money.
Home value and investment return compound monthly from effective annual assumptions; rent and other operating costs change at yearly boundaries. The owner is assumed to sell at the chosen date. Actual sale timing and price may differ.
Read the rent-versus-buy methodology